There is one very humorous meme I came across while surfing social media in which President Bola Ahmed Tinubu was depicted gleefully mocking Nigerians wallowing in deprivation induced anguish with the pidgin words: “Na me go kill una” This piece of sarcasm reminds one of what Genghis Khan told the people he unleashed or was intending to unleash havoc on many years ago:
I am the scourge of God, if you had not sinned, I would not have been sent to punish you.
Genghis Khan
Indeed, like his victims saw Genghis, Tinubu, alas, is seen in the same light by the multitude of Nigerians who have either been suddenly demoted to the league of the poor, or those who have been further submerged in the muddy waters of lack. It would seem that BAT, as his lovers call him, or T-Pain as his foes prefer, were a divine curse or plague from God himself. It was unsurprising then when many Nigerians concluded that Tinubu would employ the impressive powers of The Nigerian Presidency to further use tax administration to increase the pressure on not only their wallets but their blood too.
Therefore, when the tax reform initiatives proposed by the administration were finally publicised, it was met with a lot of noise, both positive and negative, in several corners of the polity. The aim of this op-ed is not to play jury or judge, but to examine the tax reform bills on a dejure basis; that is, look into the reform bills as they are as proposed laws, not as they would be, or defacto, when they are being implemented. In addition, commentaries will be added on what the bills mean for the polity while also discussing the issues raised by concerned groups in Northern Nigeria.
To begin with, the tax reform bills is no bad news in itself—a fact that is worthy contradiction of the furore it generated across the country. On the whole, it presents a fairer deal to the majority of individual Nigerians and businesses in terms of reduced burdens, while also reserving a bigger piece of the tax pie for the states. However, the elephant in the room, the Value Added Tax provisions, emerged as the gigantic bone of contention. While certain Nigerians focused on the proposed increment of VAT, others paid extra attention to the novelty of VAT revenue sharing formular that significantly employed derivation based on place of consumption in lieu of the status quo of derivation based on business headquarters domicile.

While the first group of Nigerians—those who grumble over the proposed VAT rates hike—can be easily dismissed using the rationale that Nigeria has one of the most benevolent VAT rates in Africa and the world or that our current rate of 7.5 per centum was a miserly value begging to be increased, the latter group of formula questioners are not so easily brushed aside.
This group, The Northerners, seems to hold the belief that the proposed formula will reduce their ratio and make weightier the already hefty VAT revenue purses of Lagos State. Lagos State, of course, is a tax cash cow for Nigeria whether one considers the sheer size of commercial value in its system or the suffocating presence of the biggest commercial headquarters of businesses in it; therefore, Lagos state, regardless of the standard employed, will always take a big chunk of the tax pizza. The Northern States, on the other hand, cannot boast of such wriggle space because they neither have the significant value factor (Agricultural products are majorly VAT exempt) nor the domicile factor and besides, it does not help their case that they either have the Hisbah breaking bottles of confiscated guinesss extra large stout or chasing Sportybet shop operators trying to eke out a living into hiding.
So yes, The Northern States do have a healthy reason to be paranoid. That said, it becomes important to mention what certain thoughtful Nigerians have mentioned as a contribution to the debate: SHOW THE NUMBERS. That is, it will certainly help if the government through The Federal Inland Revenue Service ( FIRS) or the soon-to-be Nigerian Revenue Service (NRS) can show the numbers of the VAT revenue based on place of consumption so that all parties can have the facts and figures about how their lots may be bettered or worsened by the innovation because numbers never lie. This way, even Northern Nigeria may then become more interested in cleaning up its act, especially via aggressive security and social infrastructure development for and of its people. It is a foregone conclusion that only states where peace and social development exist can score high based on the value and domicile factors Lagos so excels in that boosts its coffers with derivation based tax naira.
As an aside, in the heat of the debate, there were those who pointed fingers that President Tinubu may employ his Alpha Beta private tax collection outfit to enrich himself in the process of tax administration. It becomes important that regardless of how extraneous or sensational this accusation of conflict of interest may be, it does call for serious attention. The fact that the Chairman of The Tax Reform Committee, Taiwo Oyedele, dismissed such accusations based on the idea that the committee concluded that there would be no engagement of private contractors in tax administration is insufficient to assuage such concern. The provision should have the force of law and not just the force of word of mouth. This way, everyone can rest easy that there will be no unjust enrichment by the most powerful man in Nigeria.
In conclusion, at The Institute for Free Market and Entrepreneurship West Africa (IFREME), we are in support of whatever policies can be considered libertarian for people and businesses. The tax reform bills, by reducing tax burdens on people make easier individual freedom of dignity since Nigerians making a honest living can now keep more of their income for themselves. Lighter tax burdens for businesses also means entrepreneurship becomes freer from the chokehold of discouraging taxation burden. Finally, the concept of consumption based VAT sharing formular is in the spirit of freedom since states potentially enjoy the fruits of their labour and value generation freely encouraged in their regions. If one simply wants more Guinesss large stout VAT, one must encourage Guinness consumption; if one wants Sportybet VAT, then one must call Hisbah off the betting shops’ operators. It is, as they say, after all, a free world.
Written by: Olagunju Juwon Abraham








